{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, homes across the U.S. consistently fetched prices higher than those from a year prior, but that trend has finally reversed. Recent data from October indicates that the median home sale price has dipped slightly below last year's figures, marking the first annual decrease since the spring of 2023. Meanwhile, housing inventory has surged to its highest level since early 2020, pending sales have plummeted to their lowest in more than a decade (excluding the onset of the pandemic), and approximately 20% of listings have seen price reductions.

The situation is complicated by rising borrowing costs. This past week, the average interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage surged back into the mid-7% range, following a short period of improvement. While buyers may find themselves in a better negotiating position, monthly payments remain a challenge for many households.

This unique market landscape presents opportunities. Sellers are encountering fewer offers and longer waiting times on their listings, resulting in negotiation terms becoming more flexible. For those looking to purchase a home this winter, here are areas that could be open for negotiation and how to approach them with your real estate agent and lender.

Understanding the impact of a minor price drop

An overall national decrease of less than half a percentage point is not indicative of a housing market collapse, nor does it imply that prices are declining everywhere. Areas with high prices and limited inventory, particularly along coastal regions, are still witnessing noteworthy increases, while several major metropolitan areas in the South and West have seen significant price drops in the percentage range from a year ago. The dynamics of your local market greatly outweigh national averages.

The national statistics signal a shift in power dynamics. With homes remaining on the market longer and a larger pool of listings competing for fewer buyers, sellers are becoming increasingly amenable to negotiations. This flexibility is often evident not just in the sale price, but also in the overall terms of the transaction.

Beyond the price: Exploring additional negotiation avenues

While buyers typically focus solely on the sale price, in a high-interest climate, it's crucial to consider the overall monthly payment and the cash you need when closing. A modest price reduction may only marginally impact your loan. Sometimes, utilizing the same funds in alternative ways can have a more substantial effect on your financial situation. In a quieter market, buyers may negotiate the following:

  • A purchase price that is lower than the listed price
  • A credit from the seller to help offset closing costs
  • A commitment from the seller to conduct repairs before settlement or to provide a credit instead
  • Funds from the seller aimed at reducing your mortgage interest rate
  • A closing schedule or move-in date that aligns with your needs
  • Inclusions of items like appliances or window coverings with the purchase

Your real estate agent can provide insight into how local sellers are responding, assisting you in identifying which elements to focus on in your offer. The aim is not to request everything under the sun, but rather to ask for the items that hold the most significance for you.

Mitigating closing costs with seller credits

Closing costs typically amount to a few percent of the total loan, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, securing this amount can be particularly challenging. A seller credit directly offsets some of these expenses, lightening your financial burden at closing.

However, there are restrictions; loan programs typically limit how much a seller can contribute, often between 3% and 9% of the purchase price depending on the specific loan type and down payment size. Also, credits can generally only match your actual closing costs. It's wise to consult with your lender early in the process to ensure that any requests in your offer align with these limits.

Understanding the mechanics of rate buy-downs

With interest rates exceeding 7%, a valuable offering from a seller may involve assistance with reducing your interest rate. There are primarily two types of rate buy-downs.

A permanent buy-down involves the payment of discount points at closing to secure a lower interest rate throughout the loan's life. Each discount point costs 1% of the loan amount, and the extent of rate reduction varies based on the lender and market conditions. If you intend to maintain the loan for an extended period, this option can prove beneficial.

A temporary buy-down decreases your payments for the initial one or two years. A common structure specifies that the rate is reduced by two percentage points in the first year and one percentage point in the second year, eventually returning to the original rate. For a $350,000 30-year loan at approximately 7.34%, monthly payments would start around $2,409. With a temporary buy-down in place, your first-year payment would approximate $1,952, easing into about $2,176 in the second year, then returning to full payment in year three. The cost to set up this temporary relief in the example given is a little over $8,000, which a seller might cover instead of simply lowering the home price.

A temporary buy-down, while helpful, is not a permanent solution. You should ensure that you can afford the full payment once the rate reduction period concludes. Lenders often assess your eligibility based on the standard rate. If interest rates decline later, refinancing could be a viable choice, but no guarantees exist regarding when or if this will happen.

Do not forgo inspections in a bid to appear competitive

During the frenzied market conditions, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limit their requests to enhance their chances in bidding wars. In a more subdued market, the necessity to relinquish these safeguards is less pressing. A comprehensive home inspection provides insights into the condition of key components, including the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation, before you proceed with your purchase.

If an inspection reveals deficiencies, your agent can guide you in determining whether repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit request would be appropriate. In many cases, opting for credits can streamline the process, as you choose who conducts the repairs and how, although the best approach will depend on the specific issue and the requirements tied to your loan.

Ensure your finances are in order

The ability to negotiate effectively is limited if your financing isn't secure. Typically, sellers will favor buyers who display a strong likelihood of closing the deal. Before you start home shopping in earnest, obtain a full pre-approval instead of a mere prequalification. Understand your ideal monthly payment limit, rather than just the maximum loan amount, and solicit loan estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire from each lender how they handle seller credits or rate buy-downs to avoid surprises later.

Important conversations to have with your agent

  • What is the average time homes in this area are spending on the market, and how frequently are sellers lowering their prices?
  • Would negotiating for a price reduction, seller credit for closing costs, or a rate buydown benefit my budget the most?
  • How does the condition and history of this particular home influence what I could request?
  • Which contingencies should I include in my offer for my protection?

A final thought

While a cooling market doesn't equate to buying homes at bargain prices, especially with mortgage rates rising again, it does present well-prepared buyers with the chance to negotiate terms that suit their financial situations. With solid pre-approval, a clear grasp of your preferences, and trusted advice from your agent and lender, you may secure terms that buyers could scarcely have envisioned only a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Agent
×
Martin Daniel
{{agentDetails.first_name+''+((agentDetails.middle_name_display==1)?' '+agentDetails.middle_name:'')+' '+agentDetails.last_name}}

I'm available to help, connect with me below!

📞 Call or Text 📧 Email Me